First ship from reserve fleet at Mare Island for recycling - Vallejo Times-Herald

A 16-ton, stainless steel propeller from the cargo ship SS Solon Turman is hoisted by crane Tuesday at a Mare Island drydock. The Turman is the first vessel from the nearby mothball fleet to begin the recycling process locally. (Karl Mondon/MediaNews Group)

There is nothing easy - or pretty - about disposing of an old ship.

Call it scrapping. Or recycling. Or ship-breaking. By any name, what is taking place slowly at a dry dock at the former Mare Island Naval Shipyard is gritty, loud work.

For the first time in decades, a decommissioned ship from the U.S. Maritime Administration's Suisun Bay Reserve Fleet is being scrapped on the West Coast. What was once the SS Solon Turman - a 9,520-ton, 690-foot cargo ship built in 1961 - is now a shrinking cadaver.

Its ribs were showing last week; its bow, decks, holds and nearly all its superstructure have since disappeared. The tops of tanks that once contained bunker fuel to drive its massive engines have been ripped off, revealing thick, black gunk that is heated to liquefy it before it is pumped away for disposal as a hazardous material.

"There's the shaft alley," said Ed Mulsoff, pointing to a long, now-exposed open space stretching from where the Turman's engine room was to its propeller. The shaft that made countless rotations during the ship's 27 years at sea is now gone.

Sections of it, cut in 20-foot lengths, sat nearby, like nearly every other part of the Turman. They will later be sold as scrap steel.

"Ninety-nine percent of it is recyclable," said Mulsoff, the dry dock superintendent for Allied Defense Recycling, the company breaking up the ship.

The Turman sat anchored in Suisun Bay for nearly 23 years, slowly falling apart. It was one of 25 ships that the

Maritime Administration agreed in April 2010 to remove by next year to settle a lawsuit brought by environmental groups. They sued after government reports showed tons of hazardous material, mostly flaking lead paint, were falling from the ships and polluting the bay.

Allied Defense Recycling was awarded a $3.1 million no-bid contract to dispose of two of those ships at Mare Island. The SS President, a vessel similar to the Turman, will be next.

Other decommissioned ships - some dating from World War II - from what is commonly called the Mothball Fleet have been hauled, for years, to ship-breaking yards in Brownsville, Texas.

A California scrapping operation "is a win for the environment," U.S. Maritime Administration Administrator David Matsuda said when he visited the dry docks earlier this year. "We have a (disposal) plan, we have a schedule. Some of the ships in Suisun Bay are the highest environmental hazards in the country."

After the President is gone, there are no guarantees that others from the Suisun fleet will follow them to the Vallejo dry dock. As many as 50 ships remaining in the bay are scheduled for demolition.

Allied now must bid for the disposal contracts, mostly against Texas companies.

Even though ships taken to Texas first must be cleaned of underwater marine growth and then towed 5,000 miles, including passage through the Panama Canal, the Gulf Coast can still prove to be a less expensive option than Vallejo.

In April, the company lost a chance to scrap four more ships - a $2.5 million contract - when it was outbid by about $20,000, said Gary Whitney, an Allied owner. Despite the geographic advantage his company enjoys, vastly less expensive labor in Texas and the cost of complying with environmental regulations in California still put him at a disadvantage, he said.

His company now has bids in on more vessels. No awards have been announced.

As workers continued to tear slowly toward the Turman's keel last week, the reduction of the ship that once made runs between New Orleans and European ports seemed incredible. In the end, no piece longer than four feet is left.

Breaking down a ship the size of the Turman takes about 40,000 worker hours, or 1,666 days, said Whitney. The work started in February and should be finished in a few weeks.

Outside Whitney's office, it is easy to see why the work takes so long.

Workers with torches that spew flames as long as three feet cut down pieces of the ship that have been dumped by a crane alongside the dry dock. The pieces eventually are compressed into large containers, trucked to the Port of Oakland and shipped to a steel foundry in South Korea, Mulsoff said.

For Mulsoff, who worked as a civilian employee of the Navy at Mare Island for 37 years before retiring 16 years ago, the job is a bit of a comeback. He estimated that while working for the Navy, he guided vessels, mostly nuclear submarines, into the dry docks more than 200 times.

"We built nuclear submarines from the keel up and put them in service," he said. "We refueled them. We took them out of service."

The Turman is the first ship he has dismantled.

Mulsoff stood alongside the dry dock as workers with torches cut away a section of the ship that he estimated weighed 26,000 pounds. The air was filled with the smell of acetylene. Suddenly, a horn blew from a huge crane that sits on tracks ringing the dry dock.

The crane slowly lifted the chunk of ship, then chugged along on its track, finally depositing the piece where workers could reduce it further.